Put your back into it! Structure in the Chinese internal martial arts

Common to all the internal arts is an emphasis on sound posture and physical structure as a core foundation. You start with the external, and then move inwards, in through the layers of the body… and the mind. But, just for emphasis, you start with the external.

Many devote hours to Zhan Zhuang, or “standing post” practices, whilst others disregard such “boring” elements of training, or just pay them lip service, in favour of more exciting and enjoyable dynamic forms and partner work. Sure, it is certainly possible to train forms while remaining mindful of maintaining good posture. And it’s a lot of fun moving through the forms and playing with others. (Just moving in any manner that isn’t the customary “walk, sit, or lie down” is joyful – something that children intuitively know, but adults swiftly forget.)

But is that posture really going to be ingrained in quite the same way. What happens when you get pressed or tested?

When we stand, we soak our awareness in through the body. We sense, adjust, relax, tweak, stretch, relax, tweak some more. We get to know our bodies and feel how the parts are connected, and how moving one part influences the whole, like waves spreading out from a raindrop falling in a still pond.

Before any internal power can be developed, which arises largely through creating this whole-body interconnection through the fascia and connective tissues, and through an internal process of relaxation and release, a basically sound physical structure must be found. If that underlying framework has not been established, power cannot be generated, and any application of technique will be easily undermined.

At very high levels of skill, it would appear this is no longer the case, and power can be returned even from some very awkward or compromised positions, but certainly for the novice or intermediate practitioner, good structure is a crucial foundation.

Despite some very different emphases, techniques, footwork, and movement principles, the fundamental physical alignments are very similar, if not identical, for Taijiquan, Xingyiquan, Baguazhang, and Wing Chun. Stances can vary between shoulder-width and narrower, but in all four the leg joints are kept lightly flexed and the hips dropped, relaxing the lower back muscles to allow the pelvis to posteriorly rotate and the lumbar spine to lengthen.

The shoulders and elbows are sunk to maintain connection between the abdominal centre and the arms and hands. A distance is kept between elbows and torso, and the shoulder and elbow joints are opened and extended to allow force to be transferred through them, and not get caught in the joint itself. Fingers are gently stretched and enlivened to engage and connect the sinews, and the back of the head is drawn gently up and back to keep the integrity of the upper spine. The eyes are soft, the mind quiet, the senses listening, the breathing deep.

And thus do many practise the forms of their chosen art, with perfect structure and appropriate state of mind, calm and aware, slowly developing internal relaxation and power through years of dedication. But all too often, as soon as an opponent is placed before them, whether that be in sparring practice, or more cooperative play such as Chi Sau or push-hands, all structural integrity is swiftly forgotten.

Why should this be? The focus has shifted. The attention has moved from inside to outside. They are focused on what their opponent or partner is doing, and how to overcome them or defend themselves, rather than being aware of their own internal state. Two things can break: the mind or the body… or both.

The mind can become perturbed, anxious, angry, or proud, and this tension can translate into muscular tension and haste of movement that disrupts the body’s integrity and leaves it open to manipulation. Or the body can lose its structure, severing its connection to the ground and its own internal connectivity. When the relationship between the parts is unbalanced, the whole body is disharmonious and susceptible to external pressures.

For someone who has practised, tested and played for years or decades, this should be less of an issue, as the fundamental structure should be fully integrated and unconsciously always present. Even so, the unpredictable actions of a training partner, and especially those of an aggressive opponent, are highly likely to disturb the mind, induce muscular tension, or disrupt the basic skeletal alignments.

When the physical geometry is correct, the internal connections established, and the mind and muscles sufficiently relaxed, an incoming force can be directed through the body to the floor. It can even be returned into the body of the opponent if the practitioner is skilful enough, and can stay more relaxed than their opponent.

Keeping the muscles relaxed allows power to be transferred through the body from the abdominal core and turning waist. But this can be difficult to maintain when receiving pressure from an opponent. Tension can arise before you are even aware it is there, both in body and mind. One of the most effective ways to keep this from happening is to return to the physical structure, and in particular the back.

The spine is the keystone of our structure. If we can keep the crown lifted, and maintain a feeling of rising up through the spinal column, this provides integrity to the rest of the body. With an opponent in front of us, it is very easy for the upper back and shoulders to round, or for the neck to crane forwards as we keep a forward-moving intention or become acutely focused on our opponent’s movements.

But if we can keep the gaze soft, feeling our opponent more than we watch them, and not have our attention drawn inwards in this way, our own power is hugely increased. Staying relaxed and vertically aligned, we can find Peng: that soft, inflated power that makes it very difficult for an opponent to fold our joints or otherwise destroy our alignments.

Simply by keeping our awareness partially inside, sitting the shoulders and scapulae neutrally, and rising up through the back, we can make a massive difference to our ability to generate power, and to resist incoming forces. When somebody is moving towards you with Peng, it feels like an unstoppable force that cannot be resisted by direct muscular opposition, no matter how many kilos you can bench press. You can’t stop the tide.

I have felt this integrity of structure in my own Taijiquan and Xingyiquan teachers. One in particular is female and has a much smaller frame than my own, and yet when I apply pressure against her Ward Off posture, or indeed any posture, all of my strength is absorbed without effort. She never loses that relaxed expression of body and mind, and simply redirects my power through her body, as though she is not there at all: “taking the force to emptiness”.

Likewise, I have felt this in certain Wing Chun practitioners, and particularly those who have trained in schools following the lineage of Sigung (Grandmaster) Chu Shong Tin. A very relaxed power flows into the arms through the rising energy in the spine, and the external structure is absolutely solid. Neither dense nor tense, but light and springy like an inflated ball. And utterly unrelenting. Yes, the power of internal martial arts is “soft”, but it is also preternaturally strong. Water is soft. But the tide…

There is something in the Yi, as well; a relaxed yet unyielding intent, which reminds me of the forward-moving principle of Xingyiquan, to attack and move forwards without regard for whatever your opponent is doing. But a mind-intention is no use without effective body mechanics. A whole-body forwards movement, driven from the legs, hips and centre of mass, harnesses much more power than the isolated mechanical movements of a disconnected limb. This can be seen very clearly in forms like Five Elements Xingyi, but of course is equally present in the other internal arts.

The positioning and flow of energy within the thoracic spine is key. Here is the conduit of power from the sacrum, up the spine and out to the arms. It is an interesting exercise to find space between the vertebrae, and to seek a sense of openness in this area, without sticking out the chest or introducing any tension.

How much can you draw up the crown, and how much can you sink the pelvis away from the ribcage, without distorting the natural curve of the spine? This is a process of release, not of effort. Once tension manifests, internal power is lost. Unless of course that tension is the kind of torsional power we seek in Baguazhang, where deliberate internal twisting and releasing adds energy to our movements.

Whether in Cheng Bao, San Ti Shi, Dragon Palm, Ward Off, or just moving very, very slowly through Siu Nim Tao (or indeed any internal martial arts Tao Lu), paying attention to the upper back can bring a coherence and connection to the body, and profoundly affect the way in which the entire body moves. With the head upright, the spine aligned with gravity, and the soft tissues sunk and relaxed, we can move not only with great power and strength, but also with grace, unity, efficiency, and ease.

This is something we can train all the time, in our everyday lives. Most of us slouch or drop the head forwards, particularly in this age of comfy sofas and screen addiction. By staying aware of our spinal alignments and the position of the skull, as well as the relaxation of the trapezius and other back muscles, good martial posture can become a natural habit for daily living. And by regularly practising gentle stretching and loosening exercises, and mobilising the joints and spine, we can keep our spines supple and healthy and our lives healthy and long. To paraphrase Joseph Pilates, we are as young as our spines.

What’s more, practising this upwards extension of the spine directly translates into our mental state, too, helping us to be more relaxed, confident, and aware; more graceful, easeful and unified not just in body, but in mind and spirit, too.

Remember all those times your mum nagged you not to slouch? Well, maybe she really knew what she was talking about…

Why squeeze goats (in Wing Chun)?

I love Wing Chun. It’s simple, subtle, and effective. It combines sensitivity and somatic “listening” with speed and external power. It requires a searching intelligence, quick reactions, and the facility to switch instantaneously between states of tension and relaxation. Its mechanics are fascinating, especially when you start exploring the internal techniques of Chu Shong Tin’s, which seem to have a lot in common with the internal Jins of Taijiquan.

But one thing about Wing Chun that I’ve found kind of baffling is why we use Yee Gee Kim Yeung Ma for Siu Nim Tao, with its peculiarly pigeon-toed foot positioning. The stance is explicitly just for first form practice; we use a parallel stance for the other forms, and for Chi Sau – so why use it at all?

I’ve heard a few half-convincing reasons:

“It stabilises the hips…” Yeah, maybe.

“It helps with grounding…” Er, does it?

“It helps to develop intention by focusing the line of the feet towards a point…” Um, okay.

“It helps broaden the lower back and lengthen the spine…” But do you really need to rotate the legs to encourage posterior tilt?

“It strengthens the legs…” Doesn’t any “sitting” stance do this?

“It symbolises the potential to move into a turning stance…” That one actually makes the most sense to me.

“It trains the legs in an extreme position in order to develop certain power lines through the body…” Yes, I like that one, too, as it conforms with the way a lot of hand techniques are trained.

Oh, and even: “It conforms with the philosophy of triangles in Wing Chun…” Should I start wearing a tricorn hat then, too?!

And this stance does seem to cause a lot of problems. I’ve spent far more hours than is good for me in a skiing snow plough, as well as teaching many thousands of beginners to plough, so I have a pretty good feel for how to take strain off the knees by keeping them in line with the hip and ankle joints, and also for the importance of staying soft and pliant in the inguinal crease.

But looking at other Wing Chun beginners, and even some long-term practitioners, I see an awful lot of knees collapsed inwards at eye-watering angles, or people shifting their pelvis forwards and leaning back to compensate, putting undue and ill-advised compression into the lumbar spine. So why stick people in this bizarre (but admittedly brilliantly named) Goat Squeezing Stance, with so much room for error? 🐐

I was watching Marcus Brinkman’s latest video (https://youtu.be/Ted7XAr3SWA), in which he shows how to develop Baguazhang’s piercing palm from a walking motion, eventually generating power through medial rotation of the leg on the piercing side, connecting hands and feet through turning of the hips and waist. And it made me wonder, is this what’s really codified in Kim Yeung Ma?

Wing Chun uses Juen Ma to add turning power to punches (as well as to change angles and get out of the way of incoming strikes). But in terms of a basic Ma Bu parallel stance, square on to your partner, does the medial rotation of the legs in Kim Yeung Ma actually suggest that you should use this rotation to generate power for square punches, just as Marcus demonstrates for piercing palm? In Kim Yeung Ma the heels are grounded, of course, but that doesn’t mean rotation on the strike isn’t implied. It would seem to make sense biomechanically, but I haven’t heard it advocated anywhere else, nor seen it used in practice.

I’m only a relative beginner at Wing Chun, so I could be way off the mark here. I could be compromising some fundamental principle of the art – for one thing the waist turn means the shoulders will no longer be square to the opponent. I suppose that would compromise the effectiveness of follow-ups or traps with the other hand.

But the external similarities between Tan Sau and Piercing Palm are hard to ignore. And if it adds power and connective integrity through the body from the ground, doesn’t it make sense to incorporate that medial twist of the leg? Is that what the Goat Squeezing Stance is really hinting at? (Or is it just a bonus goat-herding technique buried in the Wing Chun system?)

Just an idea…

💡
🤔

Qi Gong, Chinese Martial Arts, and daily life

Absorbing fully into a martial form practice, a Qi Gong set, or even just paying attention to your posture and breathing patterns, is a simple and ever-available method to realise the real presence of the present.

Formally practising conscious movement and breathing translates into a more conscious and truthful experience of everyday life. You become more aware of how you’re acting and speaking, and spend less of your life “on autopilot”. In other words, it facilitates a state of being whereby you can act consciously, rather than just react, to events around you. You also become more attuned to the quality of your thoughts, words and actions.

As a result, you are less prone to mistakes, accidents, poor judgements, omissions, obsessions, confusion, and conflict. Furthermore, moving (or not moving) consciously can help create a sense of separation between “you, the quiet observer” and “you, who is identified with your own internal monologue”. As such, your whole experience of life becomes less delusional. By simply paying attention more, you can live more truthfully – more in harmony with your actual external and internal environments – and see things less and less through the lens of your own individual preferences and self-concept.

There are lots of other benefits, too. I think a daily routine of some kind of movement and stillness practice (whether that be Qi Gong, Baguazhang, Taijiquan, meditation, or some other martial art or embodied practice) improves concentration, self-discipline, self-confidence, peacefulness, patience, and generosity.

It encourages a more flexible and less controlling or compulsive approach to life; a more self-contained and content disposition that allows you to take things (including yourself!) less seriously. It invites you to let go. And, as well as increasing your sensitivity to your own state of mind and body, I would say it even heightens your sensitivity to that of others around you. It improves your intuition for empathy and for well-judged and honest communication.

There’s something of a paradox in that these practices are kind of self-absorbed on the face of it, but the result is a way of being that is less self-centred and actually benefits the people around you. I’m not trying to claim that hours spent navel-gazing in Nei Dan practice, or perfecting your Zheng Manqing, chain punches or mud-wading step, will solve the world’s problems; but they might just improve your own immediate environment and relationships.

More obviously, they help you to function optimally on a physical level, increase your energy levels, and (perhaps less obviously) help to smooth out your experiences on an emotional level. That’s got a lot to do with getting blood and Qi flowing, training fluid and precise movements, and taking full, even, calming breaths, as well as getting into the habit of turning your attention inwards instead of always looking outwards for stimulation and validation.

I definitely feel more relaxed, comfortable and balanced after practice. It gives me a sense of being stable and anchored, and helps to make life feel less overwhelming. In particular, calmly enduring yoga asanas or taking punches and joint locks, helps you to endure or roll with whatever life throws at you off the mat; they help you to be more humble, to be more at ease with yourself, and to be more acceptant and less inclined to push things away (or grab on to things) in a reactive or compulsive manner.

Through martial arts training you learn how to maintain calmness and clarity when under attack, you learn to be less fearful, to accept defeat graciously, to remain humble in victory, and to test things in reality instead of nurturing fantasies inside your own mind. All this translates directly into our social interactions with other people.

I think training martial forms can also translate into your own natural body language, and therefore into everyday social interactions also. Standing tall, a level gaze, expansive and space-filling gestures, open palms, and relaxed body language, all influence hugely how other people see us, and therefore how we interact with others, and as a result can directly influence and alter the things that happen for us in life, too.

Finally, by practising every day you can get a real sense of how your internal state changes over time, and it perhaps even helps you to become more at ease with change in general. And change is inevitable and inexorable, regardless of whether you want it or not.

We spend far too much of our lives “living in our heads”, and in my experience this only leads to self-deception and dissatisfaction. Eventually, it will result in disharmony and ill-health. By sinking your awareness into your body, you can begin to peel away your individual perspective, and experience the world as a perceiving rather than as a perceiver. This is a subtle but profound shift. Embodied practices can be, with perseverance, a powerful vehicle towards this transformative end.

This might seem high-minded or even far-fetched, but there is really nothing to lose; at the very least you will discover a more equanimous, self-directed and flexible outlook, and experience a more mobile, supple, and energised, healthy body.

Listening inwardly will probably bring everything you’ve kept buried into the spotlight at first, bringing things up that you thought were already dealt with, or perhaps weren’t even aware of at all. But with perseverance you can learn to recognise and accept what’s there, and move towards a more conscious existence.

By adopting regular mindful movement and stillness practices, we can train ourselves to inhabit our bodies more completely, become more aware, and live entirely more creative, open, and meaningful lives.